A clear laboratory beaker filled with amber seed oil is centered in frame, but inside the oil, there's a visible skull-shaped bubble formation

Spotlight Saturday: What Is Up With Seed Oils, Really?

December 13, 2025•8 min read
wide shot of a bright, modern kitchen. In the foreground, a premium glass bottle of dark green Extra Virgin Olive Oil with a rustic label. Next to it, a cheap, translucent plastic gallon jug of bright yellow vegetable oil. Cinematic lighting, depth of field.

Olive oil or Canola oil?


What Is Up With Seed Oils!? Are They Poison? The Truth About Inflammation, Industrial Fats, and Your Health

Happy Spotlight Saturday! Today, we are diving deep into one of the most heated debates in the health and wellness world. If you’ve spent more than five minutes on health Twitter or Instagram lately, you’ve seen the "Seed Oil Disrespect" memes. Proponents of ancestral eating call them "liquid death," while many traditional dietitians say they are perfectly fine heart-healthy fats.

So, what is the truth? Are these oils—canola, soybean, corn, safflower, and sunflower��the hidden cause of our modern chronic disease epidemic, or are we overthinking it?

Today, we’re looking at the nuance provided by two heavy hitters in the science space: Dr. Andrew Huberman and Alan Aragon.Let’s cut through the grease and find out what you should actually be putting in your skillet.

The "Fry-Fog": A Relatable Reality

We’ve all been there. It’s Friday night, and you decide to hit the drive-thru. You grab a large order of fries—crispy, salty, and golden. They taste incredible in the moment. But forty-five minutes later, it hits. A heavy, lethargic "fog" settles over your brain. Your stomach feels like it’s processing a brick, and you might even feel a slight inflammatory "flush" in your skin.

You might blame the carbs or the salt, but have you ever thought about the oil? Specifically, oil that has been heated, cooled, and reheated in an industrial deep fryer for days on end? When we talk about seed oils being "poison," we often ignore the fact that the context of how we eat them matters just as much as the oil itself.


Photorealistic, extreme close-up of wire mesh fryer basket being lifted out of dark, bubbling oil. Golden French fries are dripping with oil. Steam and tiny oil droplets in the air. Gritty, industrial kitchen atmosphere.

⚠️One area where almost all scientists agree—including the ones in the video—is the danger of reused fryer oil.


The Core Debate: Science vs. The Hype

The argument against seed oils usually centers on two things: Oxidation and Inflammation.

Seed oils are high in Omega-6 fatty acids (specifically linoleic acid). In a vacuum, these aren't "bad"—we actually need some Omega-6. However, because these oils are chemically unstable, they can oxidize (turn rancid) easily when exposed to high heat or industrial processing. Critics argue that these oxidized fats incorporate themselves into our cells and drive systemic inflammation.

However, as Alan Aragon points out in his discussion with Dr. Huberman, the human data doesn't always show a direct line between seed oil consumption and disease in isolation. The real "poison" might be the company these oils keep.

"The dose makes the poison, but the delivery vehicle determines the damage."


Watch: Should You Avoid Seed Oils? | Alan Aragon & Dr. Andrew Huberman

In this clip, Alan Aragon and Dr. Andrew Huberman break down the myths and realities of seed oils, focusing on why the 'Ultra-Processed Food' umbrella is the real enemy.

As you heard, the consensus is leaning toward a more nuanced view: It’s less about the oil molecule itself and more about the "Hyper-palatable" junk food it's usually found in.


The Real Problem: The Starch & Fat Synergy

Here is the most important takeaway from the Aragon/Huberman discussion: The "Deadly Duo" of refined starch and processed fat.

Think about it. We rarely drink a cup of soybean oil. We eat it when it’s bound to white flour and sugar. We eat it in donuts, pastries, crackers, and breaded chicken.

The user-friendly analogy? The Bagel vs. The Broccoli.
If you put a pat of grass-fed butter on a piece of steamed broccoli, your insulin stays low, and your body utilizes that fat for energy and hormone production.

But if you put that same butter (or a seed-oil-based margarine) on a refined white bagel, you create a metabolic "perfect storm." The refined starch spikes your insulin, which tells your body to store everything you just ate!

Seed oils are almost always the primary fat source in processed foods. When you combine industrial oils with refined starches and sugars, you aren't just eating "poison"—you’re giving your body a blueprint for inflammation.


Photorealistic, split screen. Left side: A vibrant green head of steamed broccoli with a melting square of yellow butter, soft natural lighting. Right side: A greasy, processed breakfast bagel with shiny bacon and processed cheese, harsh artificial lighting.

The refined starch spikes your insulin, which tells your body to store everything you just ate.


The "Warning Label" in Disguise

Have you ever looked at the back of a package of crackers or a bottle of salad dressing? The ingredient list is often twenty items long, with "Highly Refined Soybean Oil" or "Canola Oil" right at the top.

There’s a joke in the health community: Nutrition labels on processed foods aren't actually providing information; they are warning labels.

If a food requires an industrial chemist to stabilize the oils so they can sit on a shelf for eighteen months without smelling like a gym sock, do you really want that in your temple?

The "Industrial" nature of these oils is a red flag. They are bleached, deodorized, and treated with hexane (a solvent). Even if the science is still out on the exact inflammatory markers, common sense tells us that "Whole" is always better than "Industrial."

The Fryer Grease Factor

⚠️One area where almost all scientists agree—including the ones in the video—is the danger of reused fryer oil. When restaurants use the same vat of oil for days, the oil undergoes repeated thermal oxidation. It literally changes its molecular structure, becoming more toxic with every batch of fries.

If you don’t feel good after eating fried food, trust your gut. Your body is telling you that those oxidized fats are not fuel; they are a burden.


Photorealistic, macro shot of the back of a textured cardboard food package. The "Nutrition Facts" header is visible but the text is manipulated so the word "WARNING" is prominent in red ink. The background is slightly out of focus grocery store shelves.

If a food requires an industrial chemist to stabilize the oils so they can sit on a shelf for eighteen months without smelling like a gym sock, do you really want that in your temple?


Practical Application: How to Navigate the Oil Aisle

You don’t have to live in fear, but you should live with intention. Here is how to apply this to your daily life:

  1. Prioritize Extra Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO): It’s the king of fats. It’s stable, loaded with polyphenols, and has thousands of years of human history behind it. Use it for dressings and low-to-medium heat cooking.

  2. Avoid the "Middle Aisles": If it comes in a crinkly bag or a box, it likely contains the exact starch+seed oil combo that drives disease.

  3. Check Your Dressings: Most store-bought salad dressings are 80% soybean oil. Switch to a simple vinaigrette made with olive oil and apple cider vinegar.

  4. Butter is Better (on Veggies): Don't fear saturated fat, but pair it wisely. Put your butter, avocado oil, or tallow on fiber-rich vegetables, not refined breads.


Photorealistic, top-down "flat lay" of a wooden cutting board. On the board are two avocados, a glass bowl of walnuts, a bottle of olive oil, and a bunch of kale. Bright, airy, Mediterranean-style lighting. High resolution, vibrant colors.

Choose high-quality heart-healthy fats.


The 5-Minute Action Plan

Want to detox your kitchen right now? Follow these steps:

  1. The Pantry Purge (2 Mins):Look for any bottles labeled "Vegetable Oil," "Corn Oil," or "Soybean Oil." If they aren't EVOO, Avocado oil, or Coconut oil, consider tossing them or relegating them to "emergency only."

  2. The Label Scan (2 Mins):Pick three items in your pantry (crackers, bread, mayo). If a seed oil is one of the first three ingredients, put a sticky note on it that says "Replace Me."

  3. The Next Meal Upgrade (1 Min):For your next meal, focus on a "Whole Fat." Use a slice of avocado or a sprinkle of raw nuts instead of a processed sauce or dressing.


Short FAQ Section

Q: Is Canola Oil really as bad as people say?
A: While it is highly processed, it has a better Omega-3 to Omega-6 ratio than soybean oil. However, "Cold Pressed" or "Organic" Canola is much better than the standard industrial version. If you have the choice, EVOO or Avocado oil is still the superior option.

Q: Can I cook with Olive Oil, or does it turn toxic when heated?
A : High-quality Extra Virgin Olive Oil is actually very stable due to its antioxidant content. You can safely use it for most home cooking (sautéing, roasting). Just avoid using it for deep-frying at extremely high temperatures for long periods.

Q: Are seed oils the ONLY cause of inflammation?
A: Definitely not. Lack of sleep, chronic stress, and high sugar intake are equally (if not more) inflammatory. Seed oils are a piece of the puzzle, but your overall lifestyle is the picture!


🟢I am Not a doctor. I am not providing any medical advice. This is for informational purposes only. Do your own research, consult with your doctor, and make your own decision.🙏

I've cut out all seed oils, except for olive oil, and almost all refined sugar and processed foods. (It's everywhere!) It's been 4 years. I lost 40+ pounds "without intense cardio!" I use simple fasting and cut out foods that have a label on them... except for non-fat Greek yogurt.💪

🎯Daily Upgrades (Free): Get short daily emails + a 5-minute Theta Routine to rewire your mindset and momentum! Free daily email. Real solutions. No fluff.

Pay It Forward! 🚀
~Brett
TheMorningMotivator.com · CompleteBusinessFitness.com

You’re Upgrading 1%+ Every Day! Keep Going!


Start Here (best next step):

  • Morning Toolkit: Kickstart your day with my core tools and prompts – your best “Day One” starting point.

Daily Support & Focus:

Simplify Your Business Workflow:

Quick Clarity in 30 Seconds:

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through these links, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Thanks for reading and supporting the work!

Brett G Waddell

Brett G Waddell

Brett G. Waddell is a peak performance trainer and researcher dedicated to helping people move from stagnation to flourishing. Through his flagship channel, The Morning Motivator, Brett translates evidence-based science into practical daily routines that actually stick. Every morning at 4:44 AM, he publishes a Masterclass blog post—delivering deep, actionable insights before most people's days have even begun. His signature systems—including the 5‑Minute Theta Mornings and the REAP Program—are engineered for high-impact transformation. Start your growth today: Join the Daily Upgrade!

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog